When Should You Disavow Links (And When to Relax)
If you have spent time in technical SEO communities, you have probably heard dramatic warnings such as “toxic backlinks are destroying your rankings” or “you must disavow bad links immediately”. That advice made sense a decade ago. In 2025, the situation is far more nuanced. Many websites now panic over backlinks that pose no real danger, while ignoring patterns that genuinely matter. This article explains which links deserve attention, which ones you can safely ignore and when it is time to stop worrying.
Nov. 17, 2025
What Is the Disavow Tool and Why Does It Exist?
The Google Disavow Tool allows you to tell Google you do not want specific backlinks counted towards your ranking signals.
It was originally created to help recover from manipulative link schemes and spam attacks.
Today, Google is far better at identifying poor-quality links on its own, which means the disavow tool is no longer a routine SEO task. It is something you use only when necessary.
Google’s updated spam policies explain how Google handles manipulative linking and which behaviours may lead to penalties.
When Should You Disavow Links?
You Receive a Manual Action
A penalty for “Unnatural links to your site” is the clearest sign you need to take action.
This is the situation the disavow tool was built for. Google’s official instructions on the Disavow Tool outline how to submit a file once you identify the harmful links.
A Sudden Wave of Spammy Links
If thousands of suspicious domains appear overnight with anchor text such as “casino”, “viagra” or “betting”, this may indicate a negative SEO attack.
A disavow file can help prevent the pattern from influencing your site.
You Previously Bought Links or Used Link Schemes
If you used paid link networks or manipulative tactics in the past and now suspect Google is aware of them, a focused clean-up can prevent further impact.
A Link Audit Shows Clear Patterns
One random spam link is harmless.
Hundreds of links from the same low-quality network or automated blog farms indicate a pattern.
According to Search Engine Land’s disavow guidance, patterns matter far more than isolated anomalies.
When You Should Not Use the Disavow Tool
Low-Quality but Harmless Links
Not every weak backlink is dangerous. Google already ignores the majority of junk links on the web.
You Are Relying on a “Toxic Score”
Some SEO tools exaggerate the severity of backlinks. Scores are often helpful indicators but not factual evidence.
Always verify before taking any irreversible action.
Traffic Drops Do Not Automatically Mean Link Problems
Algorithm updates commonly affect content quality, site experience and user intent shifts.
Backlinks are only one small factor and often not the reason for ranking changes.
A Smarter Approach in 2025
Perform Quarterly Link Audits
Use tools like Ahrefs, Semrush or AI-driven analysers to monitor trends in new links, anchor text and domain patterns.
The goal is to spot repeated behaviours, not random noise.
Categorise Links by Risk
Sort links by relevance, domain quality and anchor text.
Focus on clusters of suspicious links rather than individual ones.
Only Disavow Links When Justified
A good rule is simple: if you could confidently explain your decision in a reconsideration request, it is likely valid.
Strengthen Your Profile With Better Links
One high-quality editorial link can outweigh hundreds of weak ones.
Building strong backlinks reduces the need for disavow work.
Remember That Disavows Are Permanent
Once Google processes a disavow file, those links stop contributing to your authority.
Removing valuable links by mistake can set your site back significantly.
As DevriX’s 2025 disavow analysis highlights, disavowing should be precise and deliberate.
Final Word
Disavowing is not a routine part of SEO maintenance. It is a targeted tool used only when genuine harm is clear.
If you are not experiencing a manual action, a coordinated spam attack or a pattern of manipulative links, you are likely fine.
Focus on publishing better content, strengthening your backlink profile and monitoring trends.
But if you do spot real signs of damage, run a full backlink audit and be prepared to disavow strategically.
Sources
- Google. (2024). Spam Policies for Web Search. https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies?utm_source=chatgpt.com
- Google. (2024). Disavow Links Tool. https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/2648487?hl=en&utm_source=chatgpt.com
- Search Engine Land. (2025). How to Disavow Backlinks. https://searchengineland.com/guide/how-to-disavow-backlinks
- DevriX. (2025). Google Disavow Tool: Do You Still Need It? https://devrix.com/tutorial/google-disavow-tool/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
.svg){kind=icon}
.svg)