Yet, your rankings are stagnating.

Allow us to introduce the stealthy SEO culprit you likely haven't tackled yet: Content cannibalisation.

It's one of the most prevalent reasons your pages aren't performing as expected, yet it receives little attention.

Read on to discover how to identify it, what causes it, and precisely how to resolve it before it detrimentally affects your rankings.

What Is Content Cannibalisation? Content cannibalisation arises when two or more pages on your website compete for the same keyword or subject, leading to Google's confusion over which page to prioritise in its rankings.

It's not always apparent. Examples include:

• Two blog entries targeting "best skincare routine"
• A product page and a guide both targeting "organic coffee beans"
• A homepage and a service page both optimised for "AI content audits"

The consequence? Google divides the ranking potential or may disregard both pages entirely.

Why It's a Problem (Even If the Content Is Excellent) When cannibalisation occurs:

• Your site's authority is weakened
• Your CTR and rankings decline
• Link equity is dispersed
• You convey mixed signals to Google

Thus, even though the content is of high quality, it sabotages itself — and your SEO quietly suffers in the background.

5 Indications You Might Be Cannibalising Your Own Content

• You have multiple URLs ranking for the same search query (check GSC or SEMrush)
• Your rankings oscillate between two pages instead of improving consistently
• Impressions are high, but clicks are low for several pages targeting similar terms
• One page briefly ranks, then vanishes
• You're struggling to progress beyond page two, despite robust optimisation

If any of this resonates, it's time to audit your website.

How to Identify Cannibalisation (Without Losing Your Mind)

1. Conduct a Comprehensive Keyword Audit Utilise AI tools or SEO platforms to export all your URLs and the keywords they rank for. Filter for overlaps.
2. Use Google Search Console Examine which pages appear for a single query. If multiple URLs are present — you might be cannibalising.
3. Manually Search Your Target Keywords Search in incognito and note if two of your pages appear for the same keyword.
4. Employ AI Structural Audits Modern tools can automatically detect cannibalisation and suggest merges or redirects.

‍

How to Resolve Content Cannibalisation Now for the gratifying part: sorting out the tangle.

1. Merge Similar Pages If two blogs or service pages aim for the same intent, consolidate them into a single, comprehensive page. Redirect the weaker one.

2. Distinguish Purpose If you wish to retain both, ensure each page serves a distinct intent:

• Blog = informational
• Service page = transactional
• Product = commercial

Refocus the content and update titles, headers, and metadata.

3. Canonicalise the Preferred Version Utilise canonical tags to indicate to Google which version is the primary. This avoids duplicate content issues.

4. Use Internal Links to Guide Authority Direct internal links to the page you wish to rank. Avoid scattering your anchor text between two similar pages.

5. Revise Your Keyword Strategy Stop crafting content for the same keyword in every post. Use AI keyword mapping to prevent overlaps and plan more effective content clusters.

Prevention Is Better Than Cure The most effective way to avoid cannibalisation? Prevent its occurrence.

Before creating a new page:

• Check if a similar one already exists
• Review your content map and keyword clusters
• Ask: "Am I creating something new — or merely rewriting myself?"

‍

A bit of upfront planning saves a significant amount of backend cleanup.

Final Word: Stop Competing With Yourself If your rankings are stagnant and you've done "all the right things," content cannibalisation might be the silent saboteur.

Addressing it doesn't require generating more content — just adopting a strategic approach with what you already have.

One audit. One map. One restructure. That's all it takes to get your pages collaborating rather than competing.

‍

‍